Observations with an Infrared Camera

ir_7211

infra-red image of the beehive. Note the temperature-scale: the scale varies, so it is not easy to make comparisons between pictures

The seasons are turning: we have days of fireworks and poppies, of squirrels skittish on ripe conkers, and clock-hours turning back. I worry about the bees. As I walk, misty-breathed beside the Thames, I think of them huddled together in the hive, with only thin pine walls to protect them from the turning of the year.

The colony which inhabited this hive last autumn did not survive to see the spring: a combination of varroa-mites and frosty-days proved too much for them. My first solo beekeeping experience had been cleaning out the hive – removing kitchen-ladles-full of dead bees and placing them in a fire, to dispatch them to whichever airy heaven bees fly.

I did not want to repeat that experience, so decided to take every precaution to prepare the hive for the winter. I had not harvested any honey, to preserve as much energy in the hive as possible. And I had fed with sugar-water in mid-September, to further increase the levels of winter stores. But it still felt that the hive could get too cold – the sides were much thinner than the hollowed trees and stone-walls where the bees’ wild cousins would be settling for their winters.

ir_7321

“the camera transformed suburban streets into a psychedelic wonderland”

Some years ago, I helped with an energy-efficiency project in Oxford. A small group of volunteers wandered the streets of Rose Hill, taking infra-red photographs of houses and advising homeowners on how best to keep the heat inside. The thermal-imaging camera transformed suburban streets into a psychedelic wonderland – leaky air-vents glowed lemon-yellow, radiators showed orange through thin walls, and poorly-insulated roofs glowed a bright magenta. I wondered if I could use the same technology to see if my hive was leaking heat, and to identify the best way to insulate it.

ti-camera

the hive, shown in both visible and infra-red frequencies

I borrowed a thermal-imaging camera from the Oxfordshire CAGs organisation (through the wonderful folks at Low Carbon Rose Hill). I eagerly pointed it at my hive, and saw on the screen the familiar colours. The warmest part of the hive, presumably the brood nest, was near the entrance of the hive, positioned slightly to the left. This tallied with the observations I’d made during inspections. It was exciting to be able to ‘see’ this activity from outside the hive, but also concerning that so much heat was leaking through the walls.

Over a few evenings I took photos of the hive and considered my options. For comparison, I photographed local hives of different types – two WBCs, a Warre, and two other top-bar hives. But with no sense of the strength of the colonies within each, it was difficult to judge how effectively those hives were insulated – a low external temperature might mean that the hive is containing the heat well, but could equally be a sign that the colony is weak and has a lower temperature to start with. An article on the heat-loss in various hive types can be found here.

ha-composite

a Warré hive, another top-bar, and two WBC hives: note that the colony in the top bar hive is located in the centre, rather than at an end

topnolid

heat in the top of the hive could only be seen once the lid was removed

My hive has a metal-clad roof, which throws-off the readings a little. The camera effectively works by measuring the ‘light’ coming from a surface (although it’s light at a frequency which our eyes can’t see). When the camera is pointed at a mirrored surface it reads the temperature of the reflected image, rather than that of the surface itself. So to see the heat at the top of the hive, I had to remove the roof, and look at the tops of the bars. This shows where the heat is coming from, but doesn’t give any sense of the insulation that the roof provides.

First, I addressed the heat leaking from around the edges of the inspection board (the floor of the hive). Two lengths of pipe-lagging foam fitted neatly along the base of the hive, and narrow-nails meant that it could be popped on and off to provide access to the inspection board if needed. Although this solved most obvious source of heat-loss, the walls of the hive still glowed alarmingly on the camera-screen.

The most interesting observation was a knot of wood in one of the walls. I knew that knots compromise the strength of timber, but had no idea that they also have different thermal properties. The temperature-reading at the knot was two degrees warmer than the surrounding wood. It might only have made a small difference, but in the depths of winter that might be the difference between survival or death.

knot-composite

a knot in the wood was 1.8 degrees warmer than the surrounding timber

Next, I added some planks to the edges of the hive, effectively creating a ‘double wall’. The planks block my access to the inspection board, but as opening during the winter is likely to let cold and moisture into the hive, it does not seem to be a major problem. Even more so than through the summer, I will rely on the bees’ instinct and ingenuity to solve any problems, without my interference.

insulated

the insulated hive early on a frosty morning

The double-wall arrangement still did not seem sufficient. I suspected the outer wall could simply be ‘hiding’ the problem from the camera, rather than providing true insulation. So I filled the cavity by cutting old shirts into ribbons and pressing them into the space between the walls. Four centimetres of wood and fabric separated the bees from the world, and that felt like it was enough.

🐝 🐝 🐝
ir_7508

the front end of a bee is significantly warmer than the back end

Thermal surveys are best done at night when the readings won’t affected by energy from the sun. In daylight, I looked at the individual bees. In the infra-red spectrum bees look a little like glow-worms, but with their heads and thoraxes illuminated rather than the tips of their abdomens. The front end of a bee, where all the thinking and flying and muscle-movement happens, is generally a few degrees warmer than the back end. Watching at the entrance of the hive I notice that each bee shows one of two patterns. I surmise that flight warms more of the body, so the outbound foragers are those with only a warm head-and-thorax, whereas the inbound ones have an all-over glow.

bees-at-entrance

“flying bees appear on the screen as tiny golden comets”

I know that the colony is strong, well-insulated, and well-stocked for winter. They are protected from the worst of the weather, and will snuggle-down into their cells and wait for the time to pass – like quartz crystals vibrating away the hours. As I watch them bring home the last of their winter stores, I realise that I have been doing the same things – cooking soups instead of salads, stocking-up on warmer blankets and thicker socks, and settling into myself again: preparing for the long months of cold and early darknesses.

🐝 🐝 🐝

Jack Pritchard, Oxford, November 2016

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Experimentation, Hives, TBH, Technology and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Observations with an Infrared Camera

  1. Lindylou says:

    Thank you for a truly interesting article. I would like to be able to see infra red images of my hives like you have. Do you think knowing that the hives are now warmer will help you feel more relaxed over the winter? It is so difficult sn’t it? I had three good hives until this week, then one of them got so attacked by wasps that I doubt there will be any bees left inside who survive the winter. The wasps are now being a nusiance to the other two hives… So even if hives are warm enough there are other dangers lurking….

    Like

    • pritchard237 says:

      Thank you, I’m glad you enjoyed it.
      Yes, there are plenty of other things to worry about over the winter, but the camera has at least showed me that there aren’t any obvious holes where heat is coming out. They seem pretty good at fending-off the wasps at the moment, and I’ve reduced the entrance right down with a mouseguard, so they’ve not got a large space to defend.
      I hope your bees are healthy through the cold months.

      Like

  2. Paul says:

    What an interesting and unique post. Thank you, Jack. Your finding about the knot in the wood is particularly interesting. I have heard that metal screws can act as cold spots too, and some people tweak the design of their joints to minimise use of screws for this reason, or at least choose where the screws go and how far they penetrate into the wood very carefully. Of course these are tiny details but may be significant in a place like like Canada.

    I was interested in what the temperature scale on the 3rd last photo was – the extra-insulated Top Bar Hive. I couldn’t quite make out what the numbers on the scale were but as a site author I can view the media files directly, and I see they are -4 and +1, just a 5C difference. Given it was such a cold day – which would make it easier for heat to leak out – that means you did a fantastic job at insulating the hive.

    It’s really impressive that the camera can pick up something as small and fast as a bee and show one end is hotter than the other. There’s a lot to learn in this article!

    Like

Leave a comment ...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s